Key challenges facing Peruvian MSMEs in accessing the patent system and protecting their innovations
Micro-, Small- and Medium-sized Enterprises (MSMEs) play an important role in Peru’s productive structure. PeruAccording to information from the Ministry of Production (PRODUCE)[1], these businesses accounted for more than 90% of all formal enterprises in Peru in 2024, representing more than two million business units. They also generated approximately 10 million jobs, equivalent to 89.1% of private sector employment nationwide. These figures illustrate the importance of MSMEs to the Peruvian economy and their significant contribution to employment generation and economic development.
The presence of MSMEs extends across various sectors of the economy. In 2024, 44.2% of MSMEs operated in the commerce sector and 41.5% in services, while others engaged in manufacturing, construction, agriculture, mining, and fishing activities. This demonstrates the broad range of activities undertaken by MSMEs and their capacity to serve different markets and address diverse needs. In this context, innovation can take different forms and respond to the specific needs of each sector, without necessarily depending on the size or complexity of a business’s organizational structure.
Indeed, the activities carried out by MSMEs can give rise to innovative solutions aimed at improving their products or processes. Innovation may emerge from the need to optimize resources, reduce costs, increase productivity, or respond more effectively to consumer needs.
An example of how innovation can generate value within an MSME is the case of Tumi Contratistas Mineros S.A.C. a Peruvian company with an extensive track record in the metalworking and mining services sectors. The company identified difficulties associated with traditional underground mining drilling methods. They observed that conventional systems entailed long operating hours, high operating costs due to rapid component wear caused by rock hardness, and significant operational risks for workers exposed to the excavation faces. In response to this challenge, their technical team designed and implemented a technical solution in-house. This innovation was named the "Self-Propelled Drilling Machine for Slot Raises and Ducts." Unlike conventional machines, this innovation was characterized by its autonomy, featuring a permanently attached, dedicated crawler tractor. Furthermore, its novel operating system eliminated the need for explosives to construct slot raises and automated safety measures through remote control operation, covering both drilling activities and crawler-based movement. Consequently, workers' direct exposure to hazardous areas during operations was significantly reduced. The invention was granted a patent (File No. 001220-2014/DIN) after meeting the necessary criteria to be recognized and protected as a patentable technological solution. Subsequently, its application and commercial value have enabled the company to establish a strong position in both domestic and international markets [2].
However, the development of innovative solutions that may be eligible for patent protection is not necessarily recognized as an intangible asset. For a business owner, a modification made to a machine or a new mechanism that reduces production processes may simply be perceived as a routine improvement to the operation of the business, without recognizing that such a solution.
Despite their creative potential, MSMEs may face significant challenges in accessing the patent system and protecting their innovations. Among the main challenges are the following:
First, there is a lack of awareness of intellectual property among MSME owners and entrepreneurs. It is acknowledged that the government has undertaken efforts to disseminate information through informational sessions, programs, workshops, and other initiatives. Nevertheless, these efforts may not be sufficient. Many entrepreneurs are unaware of the benefits of the patent system, the requirements for obtaining patent protection, or even the importance of protecting their innovations. This lack of knowledge limits strategic decision-making and reduces opportunities for business growth and competitiveness.
Another important challenge, closely related to the previous one, is limited access to specialized legal advice. Obtaining a patent for an innovation requires specific legal and technical knowledge. Not all MSMEs have access to professionals specializing in this highly specific area of law, which can make it difficult to develop appropriate legal strategies for protecting their intangible assets through patents.
Likewise, the costs associated with the patent system constitute a significant barrier to accessing patent protection. Expenses related to filing patent applications, preparing technical documents with the assistance of specialists, obtaining translations when seeking international protection, paying administrative fees, and obtaining technical and legal advice can be substantial for many MSMEs, particularly those operating with limited resources.
Finally, administrative procedures may be complex and time-consuming. Obtaining a patent involves complying with various procedural stages and formal requirements, as well as undergoing extensive technical examinations, which may take several years. In Peru, the average time required to obtain a patent is approximately four to five years, which is among the shortest averages in the region. This situation may create uncertainty for entrepreneurs who, given the nature of their businesses, may be accustomed to obtaining results within shorter timeframes, potentially discouraging their participation in the patent system.
The ability of MSMEs to develop new inventions and protect them through patents can serve as a mechanism for transforming knowledge and innovation into economic value, not only for individual businesses but also for the country as a whole. Patents can contribute to generating new sources of revenue and strengthening business competitiveness. This relationship between intellectual property and economic growth has recently been highlighted by the ECLAC (Economic Commission for Latin America and the Caribbean) and the European Patent Office (EPO)Their analysis indicates that intellectual property-intensive activities generate significant added value relative to their share of manufacturing employment and that patent-intensive activities contribute substantially to economic value creation. Likewise, the analysis highlights that Latin American countries face the challenge of converting their innovative capacity into economic value, given the limited participation of local actors in patenting and commercially exploiting their own innovations[3].
In conclusion, although Peruvian MSMEs have significant innovative potential, it is necessary to strengthen their access to the patent system by promoting intellectual property education, facilitating access to specialized legal advice, and simplifying patent procedures. In this way, not only would the protection of innovations developed by these businesses be enhanced, but so too would their ability to transform such innovations into intangible assets capable of being commercially exploited.
Autor: Thalía Tapia
[1]https://www.gob.pe/institucion/produce/noticias/1299194-numero-de-mipyme-en-peru-ascendio-a-2-33-millones-al-cierre-del-2024-alcanzando-un-crecimiento-de-1-6
[2]https://repositorio.indecopi.gob.pe/item/af2f6c2c-f27a-439e-ae73-d28ec33c6fff

